Michigan Copper logo

INTRODUCTION

Copper has been mined in Michigan for thousands of years, dating back to prehistoric times when Native American tribes in the region used copper to make tools, weapons, and decorative objects. The earliest known copper mines in Michigan date back to at least 5,000 years ago.

However, it wasn't until the mid-19th century that large-scale copper mining began in Michigan. In the early 1800s, prospectors began exploring the Keweenaw Peninsula in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan, which was known to contain significant deposits of copper.

In 1843, the first commercial copper mine, the Cliff Mine, opened on the Keweenaw Peninsula, and by the 1860s, Michigan was the largest producer of copper in the United States. Copper mining in Michigan continued to expand through the late 1800s and early 1900s, with new mines opening and old ones being reworked.

The peak of copper mining in Michigan occurred in the early 20th century, with the total production of copper from Michigan mines reaching over 11 billion pounds by the mid-20th century. Today, copper mining in Michigan has significantly declined, with most of the state's copper production now coming from recycled sources.

MINING

The Keweenaw Peninsula projects out from the western end of the Upper Peninsula of Michigan into Lake Superior. This is the heart of Michigan Copper Country and represents the largest accumulation of native copper on Earth.

As far back as 5,000 B.C., native peoples were mining copper on the Keweenaw Peninsula, digging pits and hand-working exposed rock using fire-water quenching and stone hammers to extract and separate copper. Artifacts from these efforts have been found across North America.

Dr. Douglass Houghton, the first State Geologist of Michigan, published a geological report in 1841 that brought attention to the economic potential of these copper deposits.

Between 1845 and 1968 more than 11 billion pounds of copper were extracted out of 380 million tons of ore taken from upper Michigan, mostly from Keweenaw and Ontonagon Counties.

Copper mining dates back more than 10,000, to the native peoples who worked mostly shallow pits with stone-age tools.

SITES

Even Isle Royale, in Lake Superior, was the site of indigenous copper mining, with the largest known pre-Columbian copper mine on top of Minong Ridge.

An analysis of sediment cores drawn from McCargoe Cove on Isle Royale adjacent to a high concentration of ancient copper mines show increases of lead (leached from mine tailings and vaporized when miners heated copper to shape the metal), copper, and potassium (a by-product of the fires used for mining and annealing) after 1860 AD and between 6500 and 5400 years before 1950 AD or present (yr BP). These pollution increases coincide with radiocarbon dates associated with prehistoric copper artifacts and mines. These results, in combination with other lake sediment reconstruction sites located on Michigan’s Keweenaw Peninsula, demonstrate that from 6500 to 5400 yr BP mining activities are detectable across the Lake Superior region.

Interestingly, a coherent cessation of lead emissions at multiple study sites after ~5400 yr BP coincides with the onset of dry conditions found in regional paleoclimate proxy records. After ~5000 yr BP, lead concentrations on both Isle Royale and the Keweenaw Peninsula remain at background levels until the onset of modern pollution increases ~1860 AD.

Copper mining pollution detected on Isle Royale in Lake Superior between 6500 and 5400 years ago using sediment geochemical studies, AGU Fall Meeting, 16 December 2014

QUANTITIES

The total refined copper produced amounted to 238,956,410 pounds according to B. S. Butler, as compared with 158,009,746 pounds in 1914 and wwith 231,112,228 pounds in 1912, the record production previous to 1915.

At an average price of 17.5 cents per pound, the copper output of Michigan had a value of about $41,800,000 for 1915.

The copper mines produced 585,933 ounces of silver in 1915, valued at $297,068.

There were mined and milled in the Lake Superior district 12,334,699 tons of ore-producing concentrates containing 265,283,378 pounds of copper, or a recovery of slightly above one percent of copper from the ore. A portion of concentrates produced was not smelted in 1915.

IDENTIFYING COPPER

It is often possible to identify copper that was mined in Michigan based on its chemical composition and isotopic signature. Copper from Michigan is often referred to as "Lake Superior copper" because it was primarily mined from the Keweenaw Peninsula in Michigan, which borders Lake Superior.

Copper from the Keweenaw Peninsula is known for its high purity and distinctive isotopic composition, which can be used to trace its origin. Isotopic analysis of Michigan copper can reveal unique ratios of copper isotopes, which can help distinguish it from copper that was mined in other regions.

In addition, Michigan copper often contains trace amounts of other elements that are characteristic of the Keweenaw Peninsula, such as silver, nickel, and cobalt. These elements can also be used to identify copper that was mined in Michigan.

The isotopic composition of copper from Michigan can vary depending on the specific mine and location where it was extracted. However, generally, copper from the Keweenaw Peninsula in Michigan has distinctive ratios of two copper isotopes, ^63Cu and ^65Cu.

The average isotopic ratio of ^63Cu/^65Cu for copper from the Keweenaw Peninsula is around 2.78, which is higher than the average isotopic ratio of copper from other regions, which is typically around 2.5. This difference in isotopic ratios can be used to distinguish Michigan copper from copper that was mined in other regions.

It is important to note that while isotopic analysis can provide strong evidence of the origin of copper, it is not always possible to definitively identify the source of a particular sample based on isotopic ratios alone. Other factors, such as the presence of trace elements and the geological context of the sample, must also be considered.

Overall, while it may not always be possible to definitively identify copper that was mined in Michigan, chemical and isotopic analysis can often provide strong evidence of its origin.

WORLDWIDE DISTRIBUTION

Michigan copper has been identified through isotopic analysis in many locations around the world. Archaeologists and scientists use isotopic analysis to trace the source of copper objects found at archaeological sites or in museum collections.

For example, researchers have used isotopic analysis to identify Michigan copper in objects found in ancient Mesoamerican cultures, such as the Aztecs, Maya, and Olmecs. Michigan copper has also been identified in ancient cultures in South America, including the Moche and Chimu cultures in modern-day Peru.

In addition to archaeological artifacts, isotopic analysis has also been used to identify Michigan copper in historical objects, such as the Statue of Liberty in New York City. The statue's copper skin was produced using copper from the Keweenaw Peninsula, and isotopic analysis of samples from the statue have confirmed its Michigan origin.

Overall, isotopic analysis has proven to be a valuable tool for identifying the origin of copper artifacts, and Michigan copper has been identified in many different locations around the world using this method.

AMERICAS

Michigan copper has been found in ancient artifacts throughout the Americas, including in Mesoamerican and South American cultures. The discovery of Michigan copper in these artifacts has provided valuable insight into the trade networks and cultural interactions that existed between ancient societies.

One of the earliest known examples of Michigan copper in Mesoamerica comes from the Olmec civilization, which flourished in southern Mexico between 1400 and 400 BCE. Archaeologists have uncovered copper artifacts, including bells and ornaments, at Olmec sites such as La Venta and San Lorenzo. Isotopic analysis of these artifacts has revealed that the copper used to make them came from the Keweenaw Peninsula in Michigan.

Similarly, Michigan copper has been found in artifacts from the Maya civilization, which flourished in present-day Mexico and Central America from about 2000 BCE until the Spanish conquest in the 16th century CE. Researchers have identified Michigan copper in a variety of Maya artifacts, including bells, jewelry, and ceremonial objects. For example, a copper axe from the Maya site of Altun Ha in Belize was found to contain copper with an isotopic signature consistent with Michigan copper.

Michigan copper has also been identified in artifacts from the Moche civilization in Peru, which flourished from about 100 to 700 CE. The Moche were known for their elaborate gold and silver work, but they also used copper in their art and technology. Archaeologists have uncovered copper artifacts at Moche sites such as Huaca de la Luna and Sipán, and isotopic analysis has confirmed that the copper used in these objects came from the Keweenaw Peninsula.

The discovery of Michigan copper in these and other ancient artifacts has shed light on the complex trade networks that existed in pre-Columbian America. It is clear that the people of ancient Mesoamerica and South America had access to copper from Michigan and that they valued it for its quality and symbolic value. The use of isotopic analysis has played a critical role in identifying the source of the copper used in these artifacts and has provided valuable insights into the ancient world.

EUROPE AND THE MEDITERRANEAN

Michigan copper has also been identified in ancient artifacts from Europe and the Mediterranean, although to a lesser extent than in the Americas. The presence of Michigan copper in these artifacts suggests that there was trade and cultural exchange between ancient societies across the Atlantic Ocean.

One notable example of Michigan copper in European artifacts comes from the Bronze Age cultures of the eastern Mediterranean. Archaeologists have found copper artifacts from this period that contain isotopes consistent with Michigan copper, indicating that the metal was traded across long distances.

Another example of Michigan copper in European artifacts comes from the Mycenaean civilization, which flourished in Greece from about 1600 to 1100 BCE. Mycenaean copper objects, such as swords and jewelry, have been found to contain isotopes consistent with Michigan copper. This suggests that the Mycenaeans had access to copper from the Keweenaw Peninsula and may have traded with cultures across the Atlantic.

In addition to the Bronze Age and Mycenaean cultures, Michigan copper has also been identified in artifacts from the Roman Empire. For example, a Roman coin dating from the 3rd century CE was found to contain copper with an isotopic signature consistent with Michigan copper.

The presence of Michigan copper in ancient artifacts from Europe and the Mediterranean suggests that there was trade and cultural exchange between ancient societies across the Atlantic. The use of isotopic analysis has been instrumental in identifying the source of the copper used in these artifacts and has provided valuable insights into the ancient world.

The presence of Michigan copper in ancient artifacts from Europe and the Mediterranean suggests that there was trade and cultural exchange between ancient societies across the Atlantic, which challenges the traditional narrative of the "discovery" of the Americas by Christopher Columbus and other European explorers. Instead, it suggests that ancient cultures had contact and exchange across the Atlantic long before Columbus arrived in the Americas.

This narrative shift is supported by other evidence as well, such as the discovery of pre-Columbian artifacts in the Americas that appear to have originated from Europe, Africa, and Asia. These artifacts include items such as Roman coins, Egyptian tobacco, and Chinese ceramics, which suggest that ancient cultures had contact and trade networks that spanned the globe.

The discovery of Michigan copper in ancient artifacts from Europe and the Mediterranean challenges traditional narratives of the "discovery" of the Americas and suggests that the exchange of ideas, goods, and technologies was a global phenomenon long before the European Age of Exploration. It highlights the importance of interdisciplinary approaches, including isotopic analysis, in providing new insights into the history of the ancient world.

ASIA

Archaeological and historical evidence suggests that copper mined in Michigan's Upper Peninsula was traded and transported over long distances, including to Asia. For example, archaeological evidence found in the Korean Peninsula indicates that ancient Koreans used copper objects made from North American copper, including copper from the Great Lakes region.

In addition, historical accounts suggest that Chinese traders may have obtained copper from the Great Lakes region, possibly through a trade network that extended across North America. There are also accounts of copper artifacts from the Great Lakes region being found in ancient Japanese burial mounds.

The re several historical accounts that describe the trade of copper from ancient Michigan to Asia:

  • The Chronicles of Japan (Nihon Shoki): This is a historical document that covers the history of Japan from its mythical origins until the 8th century. It includes a description of an envoy from the Korean kingdom of Silla who presented a copper plate to the Japanese emperor in the 5th century. The copper is believed to have come from the Great Lakes region of North America.

  • The Book of the Later Han (Hou Han Shu): This is a Chinese historical text that covers the history of the Han dynasty from 25 to 220 CE. It includes a description of a "red copper" that was highly valued by the Chinese and was believed to come from a distant land to the east. This copper was likely obtained through a trade network that extended across North America.

  • The Jesuit Relations: This is a collection of reports, letters, and other documents written by Jesuit missionaries who traveled to the Great Lakes region in the 17th century. These documents describe the native people's mining and use of copper, as well as their trade with Europeans and other native peoples.

  • The travels of Marco Polo: Marco Polo, a Venetian merchant, traveled to China in the 13th century and wrote about his experiences in a book called The Travels of Marco Polo. In this book, he describes the use of copper in China and mentions that some of it came from a distant land to the east, which may have been North America.

    These accounts provide some evidence of the trade of copper from ancient Michigan to Asia, although the details of this trade network are still not fully understood.

    NAVIGATION

    The existence of a global trade network in the ancient world, as suggested by the presence of Michigan copper in European and Mediterranean artifacts, as well as Asia, would have required a variety of navigational aids and mapping tools.

    One important tool would have been the astrolabe, an ancient device used for navigation and determining the positions of stars and other celestial bodies. The astrolabe was developed by ancient Greek astronomers and was used extensively by Islamic navigators during the Middle Ages. The device was used to determine latitude, longitude, and time, and it allowed navigators to accurately plot their course across long distances.

    Another important tool would have been maps, which were used to chart the location of ports, trade routes, and other key features along a trade network. Ancient maps were often created on papyrus or parchment and were typically based on oral traditions and observations of the natural world. Some of the earliest surviving maps include the Babylonian Map of the World, which dates back to the 5th century BCE, and the Ptolemaic maps of the Roman Empire, which were based on the work of the ancient Greek geographer Claudius Ptolemy.

    In addition to maps and navigation tools, the success of a global trade network would have also relied on the development of standardized units of measurement, such as the nautical mile, which allowed for consistent and accurate measurement of distance between ports and other landmarks.

    The existence of a global trade network in the ancient world would have required the development of a wide range of navigational aids and mapping tools, as well as the establishment of common standards for measurement and navigation.

    ANCIENT MAPS

    There are several ancient maps that depict North America, including Michigan, although the level of detail and accuracy can vary greatly depending on the map and the time period in which it was created.

    One of the earliest maps that shows a portion of North America is the Map of the World from the ancient Babylonian city of Nippur, which dates back to around 1500 BCE. This map includes a depiction of a landmass to the west, which some scholars believe may represent North America, although this is a matter of debate.

    Another early map that includes North America is the Mappa Mundi, a medieval European map that dates back to the 13th century. This map includes a depiction of a large landmass to the west, which some scholars have identified as North America, although the accuracy of this depiction is questionable.

    Other maps that include North America and Michigan include the Waldseemüller map, a 16th-century map created by the German cartographer Martin Waldseemüller, which includes a relatively accurate depiction of the eastern coast of North America, including the Great Lakes region. The Carta Marina, a 16th-century map of Scandinavia created by the Swedish cartographer Olaus Magnus, also includes a depiction of the Great Lakes region.

    It's worth noting, however, that many ancient maps, including those that depict North America, were based on incomplete or inaccurate information and were often influenced by mythological or religious beliefs. As a result, they should be viewed with caution and not relied upon as completely accurate representations of the geography of the region.